The Call of the Bugle Revisited – Part I: The Card Game Comes Alive

Charge of the Light Brigade by Richard Caton Woodville Jr., 1894; Credit: Wikipedia

When I was a boy in the days before television and streaming, I used to play “Authors,” a card game where players match books with their authors. Tennyson was one of the authors, and through the game, I discovered that he wrote The Charge of the Light Brigade. The title didn’t mean anything to me then, and I never read the full poem, just the first stanza.

Decades later, I found myself in a small vault underneath an English church surrounded by bronze plaques. They all read the same: A name and rank, the words “Her Majesty’s Light Horse,” and a date, 25 October 1854. I didn’t connect them at first and was on my way out when I suddenly realized, “My God, I’m standing in the middle of the Light Brigade.”

The realization was shattering. I remembered Tennyson’s words from long ago:

“Half a league, half a league,
Half a league onward,
All in the valley of Death
Rode the six hundred.”

And there they were, the six hundred, all around me.

I stopped in my tracks and shivered at the thought.

But I went home, and nothing happened for another decade or two. Then one morning, I got out of bed, and my back hurt. I thought to myself, “You’re getting old, almost time to retire.” And then another thought struck me: “Why not write a novel about a retired general facing an inevitable end in an old soldiers’ home, who seeks one last chance to give meaning to his life? “Yeah, yeah, let’s send Clint Eastwood to the Crimea!”

It didn’t work out quite the way I planned.

I researched away. I discovered that the 17th Lancers, the lead unit in the charge, had a museum in Nottinghamshire. Its curator agreed to act as technical adviser. “I think I know something about the charge; I used to lead groups of tourists on its route.” British modesty, he was actually one of the two greatest historians of the charge.

So I started writing.

The original draft was disorganized; I pulled it from publication and started over. It grew and grew as I added characters and subplots. I had to add another major character to get in all the eye-witness accounts by way of interviews. By turns, the manuscript became a history, a love story, and a ghost story.

You can judge for yourselves what it is.

Anyway, it raised a lot of questions.

I always get asked what I think happened that morning in Balaclava.

My answer goes like this:

Ottoman redoubts were overrun, and the Russians massed their cavalry in the valley for a major frontal attack. The British base was lightly defended and exposed, and the 93rd Highlanders were rushed to the front. They did not have time to form into the four-deep formation used by infantry to defend against cavalry. They stood two-deep—a “thin red line tipped with steel.” Their commander’s orders were simple: "There is no retreat from here, men. You must die where you stand.”

They held; the Russians retreated.

The Russians tried another assault over one side of the valley. British heavy cavalry charged uphill and routed a force four times larger. Tennyson wrote another poem about the Charge of the Heavy Brigade.

By 10 AM or so, as far as the British commanders on the hill overlooking the valley and its offshoots could see, the road to Sebastopol and maybe the end of the war was open. All that remained was to take out a line of cannon stretching across the valley. Simple: send in a high-speed cavalry unit that would sweep along the mountains to the South around the guns and attack from the side or rear. The order was concise: "Lord Raglan wishes the cavalry to advance rapidly to the front, follow the enemy, and try to prevent the enemy from carrying away the guns."

And there lay the seeds of tragedy.

 Commanders on the hill had a different view from those commanding the Light Brigade. Those on the ground saw only the guns straight ahead, a suicide mission.

The Brigade formed for the charge, and riders bunched “knee to knee” to create a solid line of horsemen and lances.

 At 11:10, the bugles blew.

What followed was the stuff of legend.

The six hundred-plus horsemen of the Light Brigade began with an initial walk, their dark blue figures followed by the slightly larger Heavy Brigade in red. Acoustics that morning were superb.

Watchers on the ridge overlooking the valley could hear dogs barking in Balaclava over two miles away. The horsemen moved in silence; the night’s rain had softened the earth, so the horses’ hooves made no sound. Onlookers could hear the jingle of the harness and the creak of saddles. Sergeants’ shouts carried across the valley as they dressed the lines to military perfection. Horseman after horseman passed below the ridge, sitting tall in their saddles, sabers held tight to their chest, their faces expressionless.

Three lines of men moved as one, as the morning sun broke through the evening’s clouds.

Banners fluttered in the light breeze.

Bugle calls crossed the valley.

Birds circled overhead.

Evening mists cleared.

The sun shone brightly.

Onlookers had the sense that something profound was about to happen. Reporters opened their notebooks; artists bent to their easels.

Almost immediately, it was obvious to those above that the Light Brigade was heading straight for the waiting guns. Captain Nolan charged from his position in the van, shouting and waving his sword to get Cardigan’s attention. He was killed by the first shell fired as he caught up with Cardigan. And then there was no stopping the Brigade. Everybody on the hill watched in horror as horseman after horseman rode past below, “all glittering and proud.”

The guns opened up.

The impeccable lines opened and closed as horses parted to let fallen riders drift to the rear. Watchers could see this giant accordion of death and knew the Brigade was taking heavy casualties.

And then a strange thing happened.

Horses, saddles empty, crowded back into onrushing lines as though their fallen riders had risen to rejoin their comrades.

The Bugles blew the final charge, arrogant, insistent, haunting.

By 11:20, the Light Brigade hit the Russian lines.

A few ticks of a clock, and it was over.

As a writer, I couldn’t do justice to the charge. I could only describe it; to truly portray what happened was beyond my skills. My feeling was that the charge was the last event in the way of personal war. Wars afterward became calculated, impersonal—wars of machines and nameless combatants. I couldn’t articulate the feeling when I wrote the book, and I’m not sure that I want to, even now.

Any comments?

Next
Next

Il Trovatore: Pavarotti Sings Again